top of page

Flavor Menu

Vanilla

This is the classic cut out cookie that everyone knows and loves. It has a warm buttery vanilla flavor that will not disappoint! Starts at $65 a dozen. 

Chocolate 

This is the first cookie flavor I decorated! It has a rich chocolate flavor (not super sweet like a Hershey’s bar). This cookie is delicious and indulgent. I like to describe it as if a brownie and a cookie had a baby! Starts at $65 a dozen. 

Natalie_Beautiful_Delights-5.jpg

Peanut Butter

These cookies a full of peanut buttery goodness! Each bite makes you feel like you are eating peanut butter right out the jar with a big spoon. Starts at $65 per dozen.

Peanut Butter Banana

These cookies are soft and delicious with a wonderful peanut butter flavor and that delightful aftertaste of banana that comes through. Each batch is made with real banana! Starts at $67 per dozen.

Chocolate Chip 

Ah, the classic chocolate chip cookie. What is there to not love about a cookie filled with bits of chocolate in every bite? These cookies are made with mini chocolate chips that inundate the dough making these the perfect option for all chocolate chip cookie lovers. Starts at $68 per dozen.

Birthday Cake

Loaded with sprinkles and a delicious cake batter flavor, you can't go wrong with these cookies! Starts at $68 per dozen.

Oatmeal Butterscotch 

I am in love with this flavor! These contain delicious butterscotch chips, a hint of cinnamon, and oatmeal to make you feel like your making a healthy choice. Except these aren't healthy because you will want to keep eating them! Starts at $68 per dozen. 

Toffee Snickerdoodle

That sweet cinnamon sugar taste with a hint of tang that we all love about snickerdoodles in cut out cookie form with bits of toffee throughout.  Starts at $68 per dozen.

Natalie_Beautiful_Delights-56.jpg

Cinnamon Bun

It's that yummy cinnamon flavor with a hint of cream cheese that tastes like a fresh baked cinnamon bun! Starts at $68 per dozen.

Cookies and Cream

This flavor uses crushed Oreo cookies to make this a delicious experience for all cookies and cream lovers out there! Starts at $68 per dozen.

Strawberry

The delicious taste of strawberries in cookie form! These refreshing cookies are a pretty light pink and make it feel like summer all year round. Starts at $68 per dozen.

Red Velvet

These cookies boast the rich flavor of a red velvet cake with cocoa and a hint of tang. They are a beautiful deep red which make for a stunning cookie! Starts at $68 per dozen.

Natalie_Beautiful_Delights-3.jpg

Lemon Poppy Seed

I have always been a HUGE fan of lemon poppy seed and this cookie is no exception! It is sweet, lemony, and all around divine! Starts at $68 per dozen.

Cinnamon Graham Cracker

Made with honey and graham flour, these cookies are like a soft graham cracker! My husband says they taste like Teddy Grahams. Starts at $68 per dozen.

Cookie Butter

Have you ever had cookie butter? If not, go buy some now - it is delicious! Just like the cookie butter, these cookies are made with Biscoff cookies. They are a spiced, dark caramel flavor.  Starts at $70 per dozen.

Citrus Vanilla Bean

This cookie is flavored with orange and real vanilla bean paste. It has a light, refreshing flavor and is pretty with flecks of vanilla bean throughout the dough. Starts at $70 per dozen.

Seasonal FLAVORS

Pumpkin Spice

This cookie will give you all the pumpkin feels! The warm flavors of pumpkin and cinnamon make these the perfect seasonal cookie. Starts at $68 per dozen.

Apple Cider

Nothing says fall like a cup of hot apple cider! These cookies taste just like it - warm notes of apples and spices will bring a smile to your face! Starts at $68 per dozen.

White Chocolate Cranberry Orange

For this amazing cookie I zest 4 oranges, chop cranberries, and chop Ghirardelli white chocolate to add to the dough. Starts at $70 per dozen. 

Gingerbread

There are so many kinds of gingerbread! This one has a hearty dose of molasses, delectable blend of spices, and a hint of orange. It is deliciously soft! Starts at $70 per dozen. 

bottom of page